“As a Product Manager, I have a responsibility to build products that delight all stakeholders.”
Product and Solution Management
Product Management is responsible for defining and supporting the building of desirable, feasible, viable, and sustainable products that meet customer needs over the product-market lifecycle.To do this, they collaborate with a wide range of people to identify and define customer needs, understand the Solution Context, and develop the Program Vision, Roadmap, and Features required to meet these needs. Then, they support the ARTs in delivering value through the Program Kanban (/program-andsolution- kanbans/) and Continuous Delivery Pipeline (/continuous-delivery-pipeline/).
Solution Management is responsible for defining and supporting the building of desirable, feasible, viable and sustainable large scale business solutions that meet customer needs over time.They coordinate the work of multiple Product Managers, ARTs, and Suppliers through a set of Capabilities defined in the Solution Vision, Solution Roadmap, and Solution Intent. These artifacts are similar in intent to those created by Product Managers, extended to support the additional complexity inherent in large solutions.
This article describes the roles that Product Management and Solution Management play in SAFe. These roles scale in relationship to the complexity of a solution: some solutions may only need a single Product Manager while larger solutions will need an entire team.
Effective product and solution management is driven by a customer-centric mindset in which the customer is placed at the center of every decision. Supported by the tools and techniques of Design Thinking, this mindset focuses the entire organization on creating desirable, viable, feasible and sustainable solutions.
Internal vs. External Customers
Product management begins with a clear definition of the customer. Customers are the ultimate buyer of every Solution. They are an integral part of the Lean-Agile development process and the Value Stream and have specific responsibilities in SAFe.
SAFe defines two kinds of customers: Internal and External. Each is described next.
- Internal customers are part of the enterprise. An example would be the manager of a bank’s credit underwriting function who uses an internal credit scoring solution created by the internal IT department. Because internal solutions often support many operational value streams, there may be several internal product managers (Figure 1).
- External customers are outside the enterprise. The relationship between the enterprise and external customers takes many forms:
- Business-to-Business (B2B), such as an enterprise software vendor providing a payroll solution
- Business-to-Professional (B2P), such as a software vendor who sells graphic design tools to marketing professionals
- Business-to-Consumer (B2C), such as a software vendor that sells home design tools to homeowners
As illustrated in Figure 2, the relationships of product managers to their customers vary based on the structure of the operational and development value streams. It is common for internal and external product managers to work together in developing the total solution. As described in the customer-centricity article, market research informs the customer relationship.
Some Product Managers are responsible for solutions in which the customer is the direct buyer of the solution, as Figure 2 illustrates. In this case, the development value stream and the operational value stream are one and the same. The solution can be a final product that’s sold or deployed directly. In other cases, the solution may need to be embedded into a broader Solution Context, such as a system of systems.
Responsibilities of Product Management
The primary responsibilities of product management fall into four main areas (Figure 4):
- Meet business goals – Products and solutions must meet the economic business goals established by the portfolio
- Get it built – Product Managers collaborate with Agile Release Trains (ARTs) and Solution Trains to build the required functionality
- Get it off the shelf – Internally, Product Managers collaborate with IT to ensure solutions are deployed to internal customers and users; externally, Product Managers collaborate with an even larger set of business stakeholders to deliver products to the market
- Leverage support – Product Managers ensure their offerings are supported and enhanced to create a continuous flow of value
Each of these is described further below. Extended responsibilities associated with external product managers and Solution Management are described later.
Meet Business Goals
An economically sustainable product creates more value than it costs. However, although costs are relatively straightforward to measure, there’s more variation in how an enterprise assesses value. Consider:
- A for-profit enterprise might focus on revenue, market share, or profit
- A government might evaluate how well it services citizens, such as providing clean water or functional roads
- A nonprofit may assess how many people are served when providing disaster relief or other humanitarian services
Product management is responsible for ensuring that value streams are creating feasible and sustainable products and solutions. This encompasses:
- Developing a clear model of how the solution provides value to customers
- Understanding the cost structure and in-license models of all components and suppliers
- Creating any necessary pricing or revenue-generating elements and out-licensing models
- Developing customer-centric ROI models that align with the value provided
Product management maintains and updates these models over the product-market lifecycle and in response to changing portfolio demands. For example, product management is responsible for managing changes to the product vision or roadmap based on the portfolio’s Strategic Themes. Product management is also responsible for maintaining alignment with the portfolio canvas, Lean Budgets, and Guardrails.
Get it Built
The bulk of product management responsibilities support the ARTs in delivering value to customers. These include:
- Understand customer needs – As the internal representative of the customer, product management leverages market research and Continuous Exploration to continually understand customer and market needs. Design thinking tools, ranging from personas, empathy maps, journey maps, and story maps are used to communicate these to the ARTs.
- Ensure product completeness – Product management is responsible for ensuring the product is considered ‘whole and complete’ from a defined customer’s perspective. Products that serve multiple market segments may have different considerations of ‘whole and complete’.
- Develop and communicate the program vision and roadmap – Product management continuously develops and communicates the vision to the development teams, while defining the features of the system. Collaborating with System and Solution Architect/Engineering, they also define and maintain the Nonfunctional Requirements (NFRs) to ensure that the solution meets relevant standards and other system quality requirements. They are responsible for the roadmap, which illustrates how features are intended to be implemented over time.
- Manage and prioritize the flow of work – Product management supports the flow of work through the program Kanban and into the program backlog, responsible for ensuring enough features are ready in the backlog at all times. Because judicious selection and sequencing of features is a key economic driver for each ART, the backlog is reprioritized with Weighted Short Job First (WSJF) before each Program Increment (PI) Planning session.
- Participate in PI planning – During each PI planning session, Product Management presents the vision, which highlights the proposed features of the solution, along with any relevant upcoming Milestones. Typically, they also participate as the train’s Business Owners, responsible for approving PI Objectives and establishing business value.
- Define releases and program increments – Owning the ‘what’ means that product management is primarily responsible for release definition as well, including new features, architecture, and allocations for technical debt. This is accomplished through a series of Program Increments and releases, whose definition and business objectives are also determined by product management.
- Work with System Architect/Engineering to understand Enabler work – While Product Management is not expected to drive technological decisions, they are expected to understand the scope of upcoming enabler work. They collaborate with System and Solution Architect/Engineering to jointly sequence the Architectural Runway that will host new business functionality. This is typically done by establishing a capacity allocation, as described in the Guardrails article.
- Participate in demos and Inspect and Adapt (I&A) – Product Management is an active participant in biweekly System Demos, including the aggregate one at the end of the PI. They also participate in assessing Metrics, including the evaluation of business value achieved versus planned, and are active participants in the Inspect and Adapt workshop.
Get it off the Shelf
Product management leverages the Continuous Delivery Pipeline to deliver value far more frequently than with traditional processes. Depending on the customer, this can range from releasing new functionality multiple times per day, weekly, monthly, or any time frame that balances market demands with the goals of the enterprise
One tension that exists in releasing value more frequently is ensuring that all internal and external stakeholders are prepared to receive and utilize this value. To ensure that customers receive the full value of the release, product management must also provide:
- Marketing and sales enablement – External product managers ensure that marketing and sales have the information they need to communicate value and execute against the sales objectives. This includes regular meetings with marketing and sales to help them understand the magnitude of the value being released and how it may impact their activities. Note that at times external product releases may be coordinated with marketing and sales milestones (such as a conference) to maximize sales.
- Channel enablement – Complex solutions often have similarly complex distribution models. These can range from Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs), Value-Added Resellers (VARs), and Managed Service Providers (MSPs), to other forms of distribution partners. Product Management is responsible for ensuring that the full distribution channel is enabled in every release.
- Service Partner enablement – Service partners are a unique channel that contributes to the creation of a complete solution for a target customer. For example, service partners often install, configure, and train customers on behalf of independent software vendors (ISVs). Customer-centric practices helps product management determine the right distribution of responsibilities between service partners and the ISV.
Product management ensures that products and solutions are supported through their operational lifecycle. This includes:
- Collaborating with customer experience and support – While customer-centric enterprises seek to create positive customer experiences, the implementation of customer experience and product support practices varies considerably based on the product. A B2C offering may only provide email support, while a B2B offering may provide a wide range of dedicated support options. Product management is responsible for working with customer experience and support professionals to design the right offerings. Once designed, product management is responsible for helping customer experience and support manage these offerings, including creating features designed to improve support functions.
- Manage supported versions – Customers of complex solutions have a right to know how long they will be supported once deployed in production. Therefore, product management is responsible for defining support policies, including End-of-Life (EOL).
- Manage legal and compliance – Product management is responsible for working with legal and compliance professionals to ensure the product meets all necessary requirements.
Managing the Product Lifecycle and Technology Adoption Curve
Every product progresses through predictable stages: introduction to growth, growth to maturity, and maturity to decline. This sequence is known as the product lifecycle (Figure 5):
Product management is responsible for guiding their product through each of these stages. Note that different products can be in different stages for quite different durations. Consider, for example, the credit scoring solution described earlier in Figure 1. Once introduced, the growth (adoption) of the credit scoring solution might be extremely rapid. The mature stage might last for more than a decade, with the bank continuing to enhance the solution to maintain a unique competitive advantage.
These enhancements, such as new features or capabilities, follow a similar S-shaped curve know as the technology adoption curve. This curve explains how specific features, capabilities and products are adopted in a given market. The adoption is predictable and can be described by psychographic attributes of customers (Figure 6):
- Innovators embrace new and novel technologies. They represent the smallest portion of the total market.
- Early Adopters are quick to understand the benefits of new technology and gain value by moving more quickly than the rest of the market.
- Early Majority are more practically minded, often waiting until products are more proven.
- Late Majority wait for a product to become well established, often delaying their purchase until established enterprises with whom they already have a relationship offer a version of the product.
- Laggards represent the tail end of the adoption curve.
Note that these profiles do not apply to every product: a customer facing an urgent problem may be an early adopter of one product while acting as a laggard for less urgent problems.
In Crossing the Chasm, technology pioneer Geoffrey Moore observed that many technology products face a “chasm” between the expectations of early adopters and the rest of the market. Accordingly, product management is responsible for understanding where each product may exist on the adoption curve and for adjusting the mix of Features accordingly. For example, a product that is in the Early Adopters stage may place greater emphasis on Features that promote continued growth, while a product in the Laggards stage may place greater emphasis on Features that lower operational costs.
Responsibilities of Solution Management
Solution Management plays a similar role to Product Management for large solutions, placing greater focus on capabilities instead of features. Responsibilities include working with portfolio stakeholders, customers, ARTs, and Solution Trains to understand needs and build and prioritize the solution backlog. They have a similar vision, roadmap, solution Kanban, and solution demo activities as well.
Solution Management, Solution Train Engineers, and Solution Architect/Engineering are part of a trio that shares much of the responsibility for the success of a Solution Train. Solution Management is responsible for the solution intent, which captures and documents fixed and variable aspects of the solution. They also work with Release Management where applicable.
Solution Management is crucial role to pre- and post-PI planning, as well as large solution I&A workshops. They also work with Suppliers, making sure the requirements for supplier-delivered capabilities are understood, managing critical aspects of the business relationship, such as financial modeling, and assisting with the conceptual integration of these concerns.
Solution Management works with and may advise the product managers and Product Owners associated with the ARTs within the Solution Train. Accordingly, forming an effective extended product management/Product Owner team is the key to efficient and effective development.
Product Management’s Participation in Solution Trains
For teams building large solutions that require multiple ARTs, Product Management has additional responsibilities:
- Collaborate with Solution Management – Solution management focuses on capabilities, and product managers focus on features. Because refining and splitting capabilities into features, managing Nonfunctional Requirements (NFRs), and creating Architectural Runway are collaborative activities, they must be done as a group.
Participate in Pre- and Post-PI Planning – Product Management also participates in the Pre-PI planning meeting, working with the Solution Train stakeholders to define the inputs, milestones, and high-level objectives for the upcoming PI planning session. In the Post-PI planning session, Product Management helps summarize findings into an agreed-to set of solution PI objectives.
- Participate in the Solution Demo – Product Management participates in the solution demo, often demonstrating the capabilities that their ART has contributed and reviewing the contributions of the other ARTs, always with a systems view and always with an eye toward fitness of purpose.
Learn More Ries, Eric. The Lean Startup: How Today’s Entrepreneurs Use Continuous Innovation to Create Radically Successful Businesses. Crown Business, 2011.  Leffingwell, Dean. Agile Software Requirements: Lean Requirements Practices for Teams, Programs, and the Enterprise. Addison-Wesley, 2011.
Last update: 26 September 2019